Jack Fights Back Against Take-Two - 22.3.07

It wasn’t really a question of if Jack Thompson would counter sue Take-Two. It was more of a “when” kind of situation.

Well, here it is. The notorious anti-gaming Florida lawyer has officially filed a counter suit against Take-Two’s preemptive legal maneuvering. Take-Two wants a U.S. District Court judge to stop what it deems as frivolous suits from the lawyer who just can’t seem to win an anti-gaming lawsuit. Thompson wants Take-Two brought up on Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, or RICO, charges. He claims Take-Two has tried to violate his Constitutional rights since 2005.

According to GameSpot, Thompson seems to be requesting federal court approval for Take-Two games prior to release. "All Take-Two would have to do is submit each game to a court of law to see if it contains material harmful to minors or if it does in fact constitute a nuisance of any kind under Florida law. The games are finished. There is plenty of time to submit the games, and doing so will not in fact impede their release--unless they are in fact harmful to children."

This also from GameSpot: “Thompson's defense also appears to contain a number of factual errors and misrepresentations. He claims the Entertainment Software Rating Board found that Take-Two Interactive failed to disclose objectionable content in its role-playing game The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion. The ESRB said it found developer Bethesda Softworks was at fault in that matter, not Take-Two.

"Thompson also said that Bully was found to have 'homosexual sex' hidden in the game, about which Take-Two 'forgot' to tell the ESRB and the judge in last year's suit over the game's release. The homosexual activity in that game was limited to kissing, and the ESRB said shortly after that game came out that such scenes were considered in issuing it a rating of T for Teen.”

As if the factual errors aren’t enough, Thompson has laid out his own version of a conspiracy theory: “According to Thompson, Take-Two had still more help in breaking the law. The countersuit mentions a number of companies and media outlets--including the ESA, Penny Arcade, and GameSpot--as having collaborated and conspired with Take-Two to commit racketeering activities.”

It sounds as if Thompson’s simply up to his old tricks again. This will be one heck of a show to watch. It’s just a shame the court system’s time has to be tied up with such nonsense.

Related:
Take Two Takes On Jack Thompson
Louisiana Denied Anti-Video Game Law
A Jack Attack – Thompson That Is
Bully Gets Judicial Thumbs Up
Find more...
Comments >>

Labels: bethesda, jack thompson, oblivion, take-two, video game lawsuits